Advertisement

Wisconsin election audit conspiracy: Increasing voter turnout among communities of color, nursing homes is ‘unlawful’

While presenting his second interim report challenging the results of Wisconsin’s 2020 presidential election Tuesday, Michael Gableman requested that the state legislature look into decertifying the election, a legally debunked claim.

“It is clear that Wisconsin election officials’ unlawful conduct in the 2020 Presidential election casts grave doubt on Wisconsin’s 2020 Presidential election certification,” Gableman’s 136-page report read. The report claims that the state’s efforts to increase voter turnout among communities of color and nursing homes made the election illegitimate. But both nonpartisan and partisan reviews of the election have repeatedly found no evidence of widespread fraud. Multiple recounts in the state – funded by former President Donald Trump’s campaign – show that President Joe Biden won Wisconsin by 20,682 votes.

Gableman’s investigation cost taxpayers $676,000, with Gableman himself earning $11,000 a month, a series of documents obtained by government watchdog group American Oversight revealed. Gableman, a former Wisconsin Supreme Court justice, was hired last summer by Republican Assembly Speaker Robin Vos, who gave him multiple extensions (his original deadline was last October.) Wisconsin State Sen. Tim Carpenter called the report “a waste of money, a PR stunt, a fleecing of the taxpayers” in a statement released Tuesday. 

Carpenter also said the report is an attempt to undermine Wisconsin’s faith in the electoral process so Republicans can dismantle the Wisconsin Elections Commission, which Gableman recommended should be eliminated due to its connection to “special interest groups” – namely, voters living in nursing homes and in communities of color.

Gableman claimed that Wisconsin’s election administration provision “favor[ed] black and minority voters” living in Milwaukee, Madison, Racine, Kenosha and Green Bay. These cities received money from the Center for Tech and Civic Life, an Illinois-based election reform advocacy group. CTCL facilitates in-person and absentee voting among “historically disenfranchised residents,” which is defined in his report as voters of color, low-income voters without reliable access to internet, voters with disabilities and voters whose primary language is not English. 

Gableman takes issue with the state’s efforts to increase voter turnout among these groups, as he claims these efforts only benefit Biden. While it’s true that registered voters in communities of color tend to lean Democratic, the report overlooks the fact that white adults are historically more likely to be registered to vote and show up to the polls than other racial groups, according to data from the Pew Research Center. In the 2020 election, 70.9% of white voters ended up casting ballots compared to only 58.4% of nonwhite voters who did, the Brennan Center for Justice found – and these numbers surpassed previ­ous turnout records among communities of color.

Radio Free America — our free weekly newsletter on the fights, deals, and decisions that rarely make national headlines.

Catch the statehouse stories that affect your life

Wisconsin Attorney General Josh Kaul called the report a “full-throated attack on our democracy” and a “truly shocking example of the authoritarian mindset at work” in a statement on Tuesday. Restricting access to voting is decidedly undemocratic – and Gableman’s recommendations clearly state that election clerks should limit voter education and outreach efforts, and that lawmakers should limit “pre-voting” via absentee or mail ballots.

But absentee ballots, which Gableman’s report acknowledges were partially encouraged due to public health concerns associated with holding an election in the midst of a pandemic, don’t only benefit these “targeted communities” the way Gableman thinks they do. The Pew Research Center found that in the 2020 election, Hispanic and white voters were actually more likely than Black voters to have cast absentee or mail ballots, while Black voters were more likely to have voted early in person. 

Gableman’s report also takes issue with efforts to facilitate voting among residents of nursing homes. Wisconsin election official Rachel Rodriguez, who live-tweeted Gableman’s presentation to the Assembly’s Elections Committee, said Gableman showed videos of nursing home residents being asked to answer questions in order to determine their capacity for voting.

“People in nursing homes are not required to complete push-polls,” Wisconsin Elections Commission Chair Ann Jacobs tweeted during the presentation. “You are allowed to vote for a candidate for any reason you choose.”

Additionally, Rodriguez pointed out that under Wisconsin law, only a judge can rule someone incompetent for voting purposes.

In one video, Rodriguez said a nursing home resident appeared to be asleep next to her family, who said they questioned her capacity to vote because of her age. 

“I’m having trouble saying just how f—ing angry I am with these videos,” Rodriguez tweeted. “Elderly and disabled people, even ones with guardians, are people and don’t deserve to be trotted out as props without their knowledge to further a political agenda.”

The Wisconsin Elections Commission pushed back against Gableman’s findings in a statement on Tuesday, saying the report was “fixated on topics that have been thoroughly addressed.” Additionally, legal experts and politicians have called Gableman’s report illegal, unconstitutional, factually inconsistent and dangerous to democracy.

“Today, conspiracy theorists got exactly what they wanted from the sham investigation overseen by Republican Speaker Robin Vos,” a statement from the Democratic Elections Committee said. “Speaker Vos should take responsibility for this unaccountable behavior and make it clear whether or not Mike Gableman actually works for him, what his new deadline is, and how much more taxpayer money will be wasted on this partisan stunt.”

American Oversight currently has three open lawsuits against the Wisconsin Assembly, Speaker Vos and Gableman’s Office of Special Counsel seeking documents that could provide the public with further information about the investigation.

Heartland Signal encourages news organizations and content creators to use our content. You're welcome to republish this article for free as long as you follow our republishing guidelines.

Advertisement