Advertisement

OP-ED: Twitter/X is the worst offender in social media disinformation about Gaza-Israel war

Jennifer Schulze writes, “As this very real tragedy unfolds, it’s necessary to be smart and vigilant about what you read AND what you share. Because the lies and disinformation are growing by the minute.”

They say truth is the first casualty of war. So it is no surprise that a new war between Hamas and Israel has rapidly filled the world’s social media feeds with disinformation, misinformation and outright lies. As we’ve seen with the Ukraine-Russia war, a flood of lies (mostly from nameless accounts) are working overtime to grab your attention, to stir up chaos and to impact foreign policy. And this time, the lies aren’t only motivated by politics.

Greed is driving a lot of the falsehoods. Think of clickbait as war profiteering. NBC’s Ben Goggin pointed out that false and recycled videos are being aggressively shared, often by Twitter/X’s “verified” users who make money from the social media company’s monetization program.

“The old videos, which are being passed off as from the last day, are largely being posted by verified, conservative social media personalities, many of whom have previously posted about earning ad dollars from X’s monetization program. U.K. political personality Jim Ferguson posted a video of a building collapsing that was originally from 2021, with the text: “Breaking: Counter attacks are underway by Israeli forces as the air force hits back at.” The post is still up and has over 170,000 views. Ferguson did not immediately respond to a request for comment.”

Turns out if you pay for that blue check, Elon Musk will verify any lie you post. Mr. Musk went even further this past weekend and promoted two accounts well-known for sharing false information to generate clicks to make money. And now, one of those accounts is operating a subscription-only account that charges a fee to see particularly gruesome videos and photos.

Post on @Threads by @MattBinder on Oct. 8. Red X added by author.

 

Radio Free America — our free weekly newsletter on the fights, deals, and decisions that rarely make national headlines.

Catch the statehouse stories that affect your life

The schemes to keep you in the social media feed and clicking are many and varied. Compelling photos and shocking video of the attacks as they are underway? According to BBC disinformation reporter Shayan Sardarizadeh, a lot of that is months old and repurposed from other explosions. Sardarizadeh has also shared fact checks on doctored memos purporting to be from the Biden White House, fake accounts claiming to be BBC reporters and one post even claiming to be detonation of a nuclear weapon in Gaza.

Several enterprising liars know where to look for clickbait content. Instead of an actual Hamas gunman, as the post claims, the video is one of many that is actually from a video game. A video game

Post by BBC Verify reporter Shayan Sardarizadeh on Twitter/X on Oct. 7. Red X’s added by author.

 

Sardarizadeh knows the social media wasteland better than most, and he says this is the worst it’s ever been:

“I’ve been fact-checking on Twitter for years, and there’s always plenty of misinformation during major events. But the deluge of false posts in the last two days, many boosted via Twitter Blue, is something else. Neither fact-checkers nor Community Notes can keep up with this.”

Of course, Twitter/X could help by ending the monetization program with respect to war content. But profiteering is also part of war. Twitter/X and its users both make money off clickbait. And Twitter/X’s intentional dismantling of guardrails on the platform invites this behavior. An analysis by Miah Hammond-Errey, the director of the Emerging Technology Program at the United States Studies Centre at the University of Sydney, shows:

“Few recent actions have done more to make a social media platform safe for disinformation, extremism, and authoritarian regime propaganda than the changes to Twitter since its purchase by Elon Musk in 2022. Following his takeover as CEO, the platform has disbanded its trust and safety teams; revoked bans on extremist and dangerous accounts; removed labels informing users that accounts were associated with foreign governments (including Russian and Chinese propaganda outlets); censored journalists critical of Musk; and allowed for what users report, anecdotally, to be a sharp increase in hate speech, online trolling, and harassment. All this marks the decline of Twitter as a trusted platform for news and information.

In search of new sources of revenues, Musk eliminated Twitter’s key anti-disinformation features: The identification of verified users and authenticated accounts with a blue check mark. This Twitter innovation increased trust on a platform once indispensable for following breaking news.”

The lies aren’t limited to Twitter/X. On Sunday, Google’s search engine amplified a phony story based on a fake White House press release. As NBC News reported, a doctored White House press release alleging an $8-billion aid package to Israel had been shared so many times that it rose to the very top of the google search results.

“The faked document is one of the most far-reaching instances of misinformation to come out of the most recent violent conflict between Hamas and Israel, fooling several online publications into writing full articles about the fake news, which are still surfacing prominently in online search results.”

Screenshot from the NBC story on this fake story on Oct. 8.

 

To help navigate around the lies, Josh Marshall of the digital news site Talking Points Memo put together a welcome list of reliable sources for information on what’s happening in Israel. A curated list like this is always a good idea, but now it’s required.

Posted on Twitter/X by @joshtpm on Oct. 7.

 

If you use social media — particularly Twitter/X — as an information source for the latest on the Israel war, use this list. You can also go directly to trusted news websites like the Associated Press and Reuters. Turn on the radio. Watch the evening news. As this very real tragedy unfolds, it’s necessary to be smart and vigilant about what you read AND what you share. Because the lies and disinformation are growing by the minute.


Jennifer Schulze is a former Chicago journalist who talks media every month on WCPT 820AM on “Live, Local & Progressive with Joan Esposito” with former Chicago Tribune editor Mark Jacob. You can follow her on Twitter/X @NewsJennifer or Threads @jenniferschulzechi.

Heartland Signal encourages news organizations and content creators to use our content. You're welcome to republish this article for free as long as you follow our republishing guidelines.

Advertisement
Listen Now